Phytolon as an Example: Fermentation Red, Plant Red, Insect Red, How to Choose?

· Industry News

🧬 Who Is Phytolon? Using Baker's Yeast to "Brew" Beet Red

  • Founded: 2018, Yokneam Illit, Israel
  • Founders: Halim Jubran (CEO) + Tal Zeltzer (CTO), technology originating from the Weizmann Institute of Science
  • Approach: Precision fermentation​
  • Core process:
  1. Take the gene responsible for producing betanin​ (the red pigment in red beets) and insert it into baker's yeast (Saccharomyces cerevisiae)**
  2. Grow the yeast in a fermentation tank; the yeast "secretes" the red pigment into the fermentation broth
  3. Filter out the yeast cells and residual DNA
  4. The result is fermentation-derived betanin​ — the same molecule as plant-extracted beet red

Analogy:

Plant red = grow grapes and press them

Insect red = raise bugs and extract their color

Phytolon = have yeast "brew" the color recipe from plant genes inside a beer-style fermenter

1. Why investors like it

In May 2026, Phytolon closed a $23.6 million Series B, bringing total funding to ~$43.6 million. Investors include DSM Venturing, Ginkgo Bioworks, Rich Products Ventures, Colorcon Ventures, and others.

The selling point isn't "more natural." It's three things food manufacturers actually care about:

  1. Supply stability: No weather dependence, no growing regions, no harvest seasons
  2. Clean label: Final product contains no yeast cells or GMO DNA → can claim "No Artificial Colors" in the U.S.
  3. ESG-friendly metrics​ (company-reported vs. conventional agricultural extraction):
  • GHG emissions ↓90%
  • Water use ↓95%
  • Land use ↓88%

2. Regulatory status

  • Submitted a color additive petition (CAP 4C0326) to the FDA in 2024
  • In February 2026, the FDA proposed listing fermentation-derived beet red​ as an exempt-from-certification natural colorant for general food use (with exceptions: infant formula, USDA-regulated meat/poultry, standardized foods)
  • However, due to third-party objections, the effective date was stayed​ — not because of safety concerns, but due to administrative procedural pauses

So Phytolon's current position:

Technology ready + Capital secured + Macro trend favorable in the U.S., but the regulatory switch hasn't fully flipped yet.

❤️ Fermentation Red vs. Plant Red vs. Insect Red

1. Plant Red:

Beet Red, Radish Red, Paprika, Anthocyanins

How it's made:

Grow plants → water/alcohol extraction → concentrate/dry

Examples:

  • Beet red (betanin): Yogurt, ice cream, juice, natural noodles
  • Paprika extract: Orange-red, more stable than beet red
  • Anthocyanins (grape skin, purple sweet potato, black rice): pH-sensitive, changes color
  • Radish red: Stable option used in some Asian applications

Pros: Consumers instantly understand "plant extract" — very clean-label friendly

Cons:

  • Batch-to-batch color variation
  • Beet red is sensitive to heat, light, and oxygen; darkens under high-temperature processing
  • Crop yields and prices fluctuate with weather and region
  • Plant impurities may introduce off-flavors or astringency

2. Insect Red: Carmine / Cochineal / E120

How it's made:

Female cochineal insects (raised on cactus pads) → dried → ground → extracted with water/alcohol → carminic acid

Pros:

  • The most technically capable natural red
  • Heat-stable, light-stable, binds well with meat proteins
  • Preferred for candies, tablet coatings, lipsticks, premium baked goods

Cons:

  • Animal-derived → excluded from vegan, halal, kosher, and certain religious diets
  • Rare allergy/asthma risk for sensitive individuals
  • Consumer discomfort when they learn "it's made from bugs"
  • High cost; supply concentrated in Peru and a few other regions

If you see Carmine / Cochineal / E120 / Crimson Lake / Natural Red 4​ on a label, that's insect red.

3. Fermentation Red: Traditional (Monascus) + Next-Gen (Yeast-Derived)

How it's made:

Microorganisms act as factories → produce pigment in fermentation tanks → purify

Two subcategories worth distinguishing:

  • Traditional fermentation red: Monascus (red yeast rice) fermented on rice/soybeans → Monascus red/pigment. Common in Chinese cuisine. Heat- and acid-stable; good protein binding.
  • Next-gen fermentation red: Genetically engineered yeast → betanin / cactus fruit yellow (Phytolon route, also Ginkgo Bioworks collaborations)

Next-gen pros:

  • Not dependent on weather or seasons
  • Final product can be cell-free and GMO-DNA-free
  • High purity, minimal off-flavor
  • Wider pH tolerance; better heat/light stability than plant beet red
  • Excellent water/land/carbon footprint

Next-gen challenges:

  • Consumers don't intuitively understand "precision fermentation"
  • Regulatory pathway is slow (U.S. FDA, EU novel food, etc.)
  • Cost still being driven down; not yet competitive with synthetic colors at scale
  • Semantic battle over whether "fermentation-derived" counts as "natural"

⭕ Quick Comparison Table

Section image

🍬 How Food Manufacturers Actually Choose

  • Strawberry yogurt / jelly / children's frozen treats​
    → Plant beet red sounds best to consumers; if heat treatment causes fading, use fermentation beet red​ or anthocyanin blends.
  • Processed meat / cured sausages / braised products​
    → Monascus red works great (Chinese tradition, heat-tolerant, protein-binding). For brighter red, carmine is stronger — but not suitable for vegan/halal/kosher lines.
  • Candies / gummies / cake frosting / lipstick​
    → Carmine gives the best color saturation and shelf stability. Vegan brands switch to fermentation red or plant red.
  • Plant-based meat / snacks / cookies / dips​
    → Next-gen fermentation red is the main battleground: more stable than plant red, more label-friendly than insect red.
  • Premium bakery + ESG reporting​
    → "Yeast-fermented beet red" writes a much better sustainability slide than "Peruvian insect red."

🎈 One-Sentence Summary

Plant red:

Grown by the earth — consumer-friendly but fragile

Insect red: Produced by bugs — technically excellent but turns off a segment of consumers

Fermentation red: Brewed by microbes — stable supply, clean label, ESG-friendly; the "second supply layer" of natural colors

Phytolon​ is the most advanced commercial player on this path:

Don't grow beets. Don't kill cochineal bugs. Let yeast "ferment" the red out of a plant gene.